Archive for the ‘Class Action’ Category

HMS Financial Update

Friday, April 17th, 2009

An amended statement of claim for the HMS Financial case has been posted to the case page.

Cuming & Gillespie Lawyers Pursue Medtronic Class Action

Monday, January 5th, 2009

Cuming & Gillespie Lawyers are very pleased to announce that our firm is currently locating and assisting Alberta claimants in the Medtronic medical devices national class action. We currently require an Alberta Health care number and other various information in order to properly assess claims for damages for both individuals and Estates of deceased individuals. Additionally, Alberta Health will be bringing forth a claim through the litigation to recover their health care costs

For further information, please contact our office directly.

Client Update re HMS Financial

Friday, October 10th, 2008

McLENNAN ROSS LLP / CUMING GILLESPIE LAWYERS

We are very pleased to report that on October 10, 2008 we received the decision from Justice Rooke certifying our action as a Class Action as well as dismissing, with some minor qualifications, the applications by the defendant Banks to strike the action against them. We see this as a major success in the action.

What does certification of the action mean? Certification is the first critical step in a Class Action lawsuit. It is what turns a regular action on behalf of only the representative plaintiffs who filed the Statement of Claim, into an action on behalf of all of the innocent investors in the HMS Scheme. This will require the Defendants to evaluate the risk against them. The claim is now a much bigger amount, as it is on behalf of the whole Plaintiff class rather than two or three individual plaintiffs. There is the possibility that the defendants, or some of the defendants, could appeal the decision. But certification of the action means that we can now begin the process of regular litigation, including exchange of documents between the parties as well as Examinations for Discovery of the major defendants in the litigation.

We thank you all for your patience. We understand how slow litigation can seem, especially in cases this complicated and involving so many parties. We ask that you continue to be patient, as, while the litigation will now be able to move forward, the next steps can still be time consuming and slow moving.

We will continue to update you with any news if there is anything to update you with. But please remember that we ask that you please not call or e-mail for updates. It is very time consuming and expensive for us to deal with clients seeking individual updates, so please understand that if you do not receive an update for several months, this means that there is nothing newsworthy to share with you.

Thank you for your understanding.

Yours truly,

Lynn Dechaine (for Graham McLennan)
Paralegal - Litigation
McLennan Ross LLP
Toll Free: 1-800-567-9200
Direct Line: (780) 482-9281
Fax: (780) 482-9100

Guidant Class Action

Monday, August 4th, 2008

Cuming & Gillespie Lawyers is proud to announce that Justice Cullity of the Ontario Superior Court of Justice has appointed our co-counsel group, led by Won J. Kim of Kim Orr LLP, and James Newand of Lerners LLP as lead counsel in the Canadian national class action claim. Cuming & Gillespie Lawyers are proud to be Alberta counsel for this matter and we are excited to proceed with seeking certification of a national class action comprising all persons implanted with Guidant Pace Maker and Defibrillator devices throughout Canada.

Cuming & Gillespie Lawyers is proud to announce we have joined the national counsel team led by Won J. Kim of Kim Orr LLP in Toronto in the proposed national class action regarding Guidant Defibrillators.

A similar claim in the U.S. resolved on a global basis for approximately $214,000,000.00.

Should you have any inquiries with respect to Guidant Defibrillator claims please contact James Cuming of Cuming & Gillespie Lawyers.

National Medtronic Class Action Certification

Wednesday, July 30th, 2008

Cuming & Gillespie Lawyers, and our class action partners, Kim Orr, Lerners, Rochon Genova (and others) are very, very pleased to announce that Justice Hoy of the Ontario Superior Court of Justice has declared a certified national class in the case of Peter et al v. Medtronic of Canada.

This matter will now move forward to the notice stage, and then potentially proceed to a trial on the merits of the claim.

The certification was successful in that it was determined there was an identifiable class, the class members have common issues, a national class action was the preferable procedure and, for the first time in Canadian class action jurisprudence history in a pharmaceutical action a waiver of tort was granted to the Plaintiff class. This means that if the Plaintiffs are successful in their class action they will be able to disgorge profits from the Defendant Manufacturer on the conclusion of the claim.

For further inquiries with respect to the Medtronic claim please contact James Cuming of Cuming & Gillespie Lawyers.

May 2, 2008 - Vioxx Case Update

Friday, May 2nd, 2008

The national certification hearing on Vioxx is now set for June 24-27 in Toronto, Canada.

March 5, 2008 - Vioxx Case Update

Wednesday, March 5th, 2008

A Communication to Class Members from the National Counsel Team:

In recent days and months, there has been significant media coverage about developments in Vioxx litigation, both in Canada and in the United States and you may be confused about what these developments mean and how they affect your rights. This update aims to provide you with some explanations and assistance in understanding the current situation with Vioxx litigation in Canada.

In November, 2007, Merck & Co. announced that it had agreed conditionally to settle a significant portion of the Vioxx claims in the U.S., setting aside approximately $4.85 billion to do so. Even though those cases deal with the exact same drug as the Canadian litigation, Merck has, to date, made no effort to establish a parallel settlement for Canadian users of Vioxx and Merck Frosst Canada Ltd. has publicly and repeatedly stated its intention to vigorously defend all Vioxx lawsuits in Canada.

The defendants have raised various procedural hurdles which have slowed the progress of the litigation. As a result, all Vioxx lawsuits in Canada remain in various stages of litigation. In Ontario, there is a proposed national class action which has been brought on behalf of all Canadian users of Vioxx and their family members. A consortium of 19 eminent law firms from all across Canada has come together to collectively represent Canadians in this lawsuit and advance the strongest case possible. At this stage, all Canadians who took Vioxx (and their family members) are covered by this lawsuit, whether they take any active steps to contact counsel or not.

The Ontario action was originally scheduled to proceed to its certification hearing in October, 2007. This hearing is a mandatory step in the litigation process and decides whether or not the action should be allowed to proceed as a single class action lawsuit, for the benefit of all class members. Shortly before the Ontario hearing was scheduled to proceed, the defendants sought and were granted an adjournment in order to conduct cross-examinations of various witnesses. The rescheduled hearing was set to commence on February 13, 2008, but only several days before the certification hearing, the defendants sought to have Mr. Allan Rock, Q.C., the firm of Sutts, Strosberg LLP and the National Counsel Team disqualified as a result of Mr. Rock’s previous political career, during which he served, among other things, as the federal Minister of Health. As a result of this last minute motion, the certification hearing was, once again, adjourned.

Mr. Justice Maurice Cullity of the Ontario Superior Court of Justice heard the removal motion on February 15, 2008. In a decision released on February 26, 2008, his Honour decided that Mr. Rock would have no further involvement in this case; however, Sutts, Strosberg LLP and the rest of the National Counsel Team remain as counsel in this action and strongly believe that the certification hearing should be rescheduled as soon as possible, and hopefully no later than April, 2008.

On November 9, 2006, Justice Andre Denis of the Quebec Superior Court authorized a class action for Quebec residents who suffered damages caused by the use of Vioxx. That case pertains to residents of Quebec only and is also continuing to work its way through the legal system.

In further recent Canadian Vioxx news, a separate case launched in Saskatchewan was certified as a class action in a decision released on February 20, 2008. We welcome the decision of Mr. Justice John Klebuc in determining that litigation related to Vioxx is an appropriate case for certification; however, we note also that Merck has already indicated its intention to appeal that decision which will likely stay the certification decision and any related certification order. Practically speaking, this means that this case will be on hold until Merck’s appeal rights are exhausted.

We should also note that the decision allows Canadians who do not reside in Saskatchewan to participate in the class action on an “opt in” basis. If you do not reside in Saskatchewan but choose to “opt in” to this action, you may be precluded from participating in the Ontario action or be represented by the National Counsel Team. It will be very important to consider how your rights will be affected before deciding whether or not to opt in to the Saskatchewan class action. Again, in view of Merck’s intention to appeal Mr. Justice Klebuk’s decision, it is likely that this aspect of the case will be on hold pending the appeals process as well.

Because Merck has not, to date, indicated any willingness to make any settlement proposal for Canadian Vioxx users, in spite of their multi-billion dollar settlement proposal in the US, the current strategy of the National Counsel Team is to drive the Ontario litigation forward and deal with the case on the merits. The time for class members to make any necessary decisions about how to advance their individual claims will arise after these various proceedings have been finally determined following a common issues trial. It is unfortunately not possible to predict with certainty how long this process may take; however updates will be provided as they become available.

As members of the National Counsel Team, we wish to express our appreciation to all class members for their patience to date with this complex litigation and we wish to assure you all that everything is being done to ensure that you receive the justice you so rightly deserve.

Accutane National Counsel Team Expanded

Monday, February 25th, 2008

Cuming & Gillespie Lawyers are very happy to announce the addition of Lerners LLP of London, Ontario to the National Class Action Team for the Accutane litigation. Lerners LLP brings a wealth of experience and talent to the class action which will be proceeding shortly through the Ontario Superior Court. James Cuming of Cuming & Gillespie Lawyers is one of the primary counsel on the national class action claim.

We will continue to keep our clients apprised as to the progress of the Accutane National Class Action which will be proceeding on Ontario.

VIOXX Claim Set for Certification

Monday, February 18th, 2008

The Canadian National Class Action has been set for a Certification hearing in Ontario on February 13, and 14 2008. Lead Counsel on the matter will be Siskens LLP, Sutts Strosberg and Rochon Genova LLP, all of Ontario.

We will keep our clients apprised through the website at the determination of the certification hearing.

Vioxx Case Update

Wednesday, January 23rd, 2008

Cuming & Gillespie Lawyers continue to proceed with the Canadian National Class Action with respect to the Vioxx claims.

The Vioxx claims within the U.S. only have been resolved for the sum of $4,850,000.00 dollars pursuant to an agreement between Merck & Co. Inc and a six member negotiating committee on behalf of all U.S. Plaintiffs. The details of the U.S. settlement are available online at www.officialvioxxsettlement.com.

The claim has not resolved and will be proceeding to a certification hearing in 2008.